Dollar Punished Ahead of ECB


  • The dollar is slumping against all the major currencies in the aftermath of the hawkish Fed
  • Not only does the ECB meeting lie ahead, but trade tensions are set to escalate
  • The BOJ reduced the amount of 3-5-year government bonds by JPY30 bln to JPY300 bln.
  • The PBOC did not adjust rates after the Fed as May data came in softer than expected
  • Details of the Australian jobs report were soft
  • The ECB meeting may very well prove anti-climactic
  • EM FX is taking a bit of a breather post-Fed but we warn that risks are building

The dollar is mostly weaker against the majors ahead of the ECB decision.  Sterling and yen are outperforming, while the Scandies and Aussie are underperforming.  EM currencies are mostly firmer.  RUB and ZAR are outperforming, while KRW and HUF are underperforming.  MSCI Asia Pacific was down 0.9%, with the Nikkei falling 1%.  MSCI EM is down 0.9% so far today, with the Shanghai Composite falling 0.2%.  Euro Stoxx 600 is down 0.5% near midday, while US futures are pointing to a flat open.  The 10-year US yield is down 2 bp at 2.95%.  Commodity prices are mixed, with Brent oil down 0.1%, copper down 0.5%, and gold up 0.5%.

The US dollar is slumping against all the major currencies in the aftermath of the hawkish Federal Reserve.  In fact, the inability of the greenback to hold on to the gains scored in the initial reaction to the Fed’s hike, optimism on the economy, and the signal of hikes in September and December all foretold today’s push lower.

Not only does the ECB meeting lie ahead, but trade tensions are set to escalate.  Consider that the US seems intent on making Americans pay 25% more for $50 bln of Chinese imports in retaliation for intellectual property rights violations.  China wants American consumers to have access to their cheap imports and has threatened to retract the concessions it has made if the US goes forward.

There are a number of other events and developments demanding investors’ attention.  Let’s sum these up and point to market and policy impacts. Three developments here stand out:

First, the BOJ reduced the amount of 3-5-year government bonds by JPY30 bln to JPY300 bln.    It is the second reduction of bond buying this month.  The lack of market reaction indicates that investors have taken on board the BOJ’s message that there is no policy implication to these operational adjustments.  The actions are dependent on market conditions.  There is no doubt that the BOJ will leave policy on hold when its meeting concludes tomorrow.  Its current inflation forecast is above market expectations, and there is a reasonably good chance that the BOJ forecasts are pared (closer to 1%).

The dollar peaked yesterday near JPY110.85 but fell to a three-day low a little below JPY110.00.  A break of JPY109.80 would suggest scope for another big figure decline.  There are chunky options that expire today:  JPY109.50-109.65 (~$870 mln), JPY109.90-110.00 ($2 bln) and JPY110.50 ($820 mln).

Second, the past two Fed hikes saw the PBOC hike rates a token five basis points.  Not today.  Shortly after passing, the reason may have become clear.  China reported a series of economic reports suggesting a cooling spring wind.  Retail sales fell to 8.5% from 9.4%.  Economists had expected an increase.  Industrial output growth slowed to 6.8% from 7.0%.  Fixed investment rose 6.1% from a year ago.  Economists expected an unchanged pace of 7.0%.  Earlier this week, China reported what appears to be a sharp slowdown in shadow banking activity.  Good demand is still being seen for mainland shares through the HK-connect, and the dollar is trading slightly heavier against the yuan.  It had finished last week near CNY6.4070 and is now near CNY6.3920.

Third, the Reserve Bank of Australia has underscored the importance of the labor market in its economic outlook and today’s employment report does nothing to suggest it will move off neutral any time soon.  The 12k increase in jobs is a function of part-time employment.  Full-time positions fell by 20.6k, which gives back the lion’s share of the 28k created in April (revised from nearly 33k).  The participation rate slipped to 65.5% from 65.6%, which accounts for some of the decline in the unemployment rate (5.4% vs. 5.6%).  The Australian dollar is the only major currency that is unable to rise against the US dollar so far today.  It is trading within yesterday’s ranges.

Before turning to the ECB meeting, let’s look at the UK.  A strong retail sales report and poor dollar tone are overshadowing the Brexit morass to lift sterling.  It is the strongest of the majors, gaining about 0.5% and above 1.4 cents above yesterday’s low.  The $1.35 area is the next target, and there is a GBP1.2 bln option that expires there today.  May retail sales jumped 1.3%.  The economists were forecasting a big pullback after the April surge (1.4% excluding petrol).  The post-hoc explanation is the better weather and the wedding effect.   We continue to think an August BOE rate hike is the most likely scenario.

Brexit remains a mess.  The UK government is negotiating with itself and what comes out seems unacceptable to the EC.  That said, there does appear to some beams of light in the Irish border issue, and Ireland indicates that it will not seek block broader talks if no agreement is reached at the EU summit later this month.

The ECB meeting may very well prove anti-climactic.  It has rallied smartly after finding support near $1.1725 yesterday post-Fed to make a five-day high a little below $1.1830.  Last week’s high is found at $1.1840.  There is a $1.1850 option that expires today for ~550 mln euros.  There is a strong consensus of what the ECB will do and stay.  It will do nothing.  It is expected to say that the staff has revised up the CPI forecasts (the euro is weaker, and oil is higher than anticipated in March).  It is expected to indicate that its purchases will not stop suddenly in September and that it will taper further in Q4.  It may not pre-commit to stopping completely in December, but that would be the clear indication.

The risk is that many put too much emphasis on the reduced bond buying as a sign of normalization.  The ECB’s extraordinary policies are much broader than just QE.  Its deposit rate is minus 40 bp.  It is not going to raise this until at least the middle of next year.  And when it does lift it, it is still not going to be at zero for at least several months after that.  Even with conservative assumptions, this is unlikely to happen until the end of 2019 or the first part of 2020.

Like others, we too question the extent of the tightening the Fed signaled.  However, more hikes are coming and this means that peak divergence still lies ahead.  Previously the Fed was criticized for hubris.  Yesterday Powell confirmed that the Fed is operating with a high degree of uncertainty about some key theoretical issues that underpin the policy edifice, like full-employment and r-star.  Many don’t like that either.  But more generally, the market appears to see the risk of a policy mistake.  The pricing in the derivatives market suggests that the Fed funds may peak in the middle of next year.

Given the Fed’s move and the ECB press conference, the US retail sales will be of greater interest to economists than investors.  For the record, though, another reasonable strong report, where the GDP components likely rose around 0.4%, which is twice the Q1 average.

EM FX is taking a bit of a breather post-Fed but we warn that risks are building.  US rates are moving higher, while trade tensions are building.  Now add in signs of a slowdown in the mainland China economy, which is sustained would be negative for the many EM economies that are in its supply chain.  Korea came back from a post-summit holiday, and the KOSPI promptly fell nearly 2%.